UI Stupidity: Confirm Network Key
June 25th, 2007Here is my least favorite Windows XP dialog:

Let’s say I have a long WEP key – maybe a random 26 digit hexadecimal string [quite common]. Not only do you have to type it in without the option of seeing the characters you type, you must type them TWICE.
This is dumb.
It is only critical that a user confirm a typed password during the process of creating a new password, just so they don’t accidentally get locked because they unwittingly made a typo while entering in the new password.
Here, OS X gets it exactly right:
Type the password once, hit ok. If I mistyped the password authentication will fail and I can try again. Brilliant.
In the spirit of complaining, I do have one major gripe with the OS X wireless stack that Windows XP does a much better job with.
Head up the the Airport dropdown on your menu bar and you’ll see the list of access points that have a strong enough signal to connect to. If you’re in a public place you might see 25-30 access points. OS X gives you no indication of which of those are open or closed, and certainly no idea what their signal strengths are. Want to find one that has a good signal and is also unencrypted out of that list of 30? Good Luck.



July 20th, 2007 at 6:17 am
Hate to say it – Vista does it better. They have improved things like this. I’m not totally convinced on the ‘Network and Sharing Centre’ but the process for connecting to a wireless network is excellent.
July 25th, 2007 at 5:13 pm
[...] This is what I’ve been looking for! I’ve complained before that the default Airport dropdown is hopelessly inadequate if you’re looking to discover an open access point, or select one that has the strongest signal. Thankfully, this guy went and made it happen. Awesome. [...]
November 20th, 2007 at 11:56 pm
Hate to say it Martin – OS X Leopard does it better.